352 LED Ring Light vs. Z96 LED Diffusion

Since I mentioned I had the 352 LED Ring light, I've had a few questions about it. So before walking out the door I took a few pics of what diffusion would look like with the LED ring light and compared it against the popular Z96 LED. This is not a test of color temperature, this is just a test on diffusion of the ring light. Settings on the camera were at 1/80th F/4 ISO 640. Keeping these settings, you can see how much more or less light there is compared to each other.

As a standard I first started out with the Z96 about 3 feet away from the subject. The subject (Yoda) was about 3ft. away from the white background. You can see the coverage of the light in the full image. In the closeup photo, you can see how much shadow the light casts along with how much diffusion there is around the face.



Next is the 352 LED Ring light. I have this light powered up from my 12v battery that came with the 183 LED light. Besides outputting much brighter light, you can see how much more area of coverage this light has over the Z96. The light is also very well diffused around the face with soft shadows that wrap around the subject.



So how well does this light work? It works great, but it requires an AC outlet or 12V battery pack. Even though this ring light is dimmable, it's a very bright source of light that might be uncomfortable for your subject to stare at directly. If you're not working with people then it's a great LED ring that provides very soft even lighting. So to be fair, this should be considered more of an option to the 500 LED panel over an on-camera LED light (even though it can be an on-camera light).

The light itself is extremely light-weight made mostly of plastic. There is an OFF/ON switch as well as a dimmer knob. There are no filters provided with this ring light. If it's too bright for your subject, you could put it off to the side with a light stand. Carry a few and it can serve as a portable lighting kit great for traveling interviews. The options already built in to run on AC power or through a 12V power source make it more flexible than a 500 LED without added cost (batteries not included). This would easily run on a portable jumper battery with built in Cigarette lighter adapter (like the one I have). Long lasting 12V rechargeables are easy to come by. You can even use the batteries from 'Power Wheels' kids electric cars found at Toys-R-Us.

Considering the price. The 352 LED Ring light is about the same price as the popular 500 LED panels. The Ring light also cannot produce the same amount of brightness as the 500 LED panel, but if weight and size is a concern, this Ring Light cuts that inconvenience down to half. Besides being smaller and lighter than a 500 LED, it can be mounted with your camera for mobile use (something you can't do with a 500 LED). Price might seem high when comparing LED count, but for some traveling types it might justify the cost. You can pack several of these into Airplane carry on luggage as opposed to one single 500 LED light panel.


find-price-button 352 LED Ring Light with 12V input AC Adapter for Video

17 thoughts on “352 LED Ring Light vs. Z96 LED Diffusion

  1. Julien

    sorry i was not clear in my post, in fact i mad a mistake when i mentioned ikan i wanted to talk about adapter Jag for LP-E6 batteries, i don't know why i said "ikan". yes this adapter would work perfectly with the asian 352 rign light, i think?

  2. Emm

    Post author

    @Julien - I don't know if ikan makes a 352 LED ring light. These ring lights are all coming from Asia I believe. If you want to make an adapter for LP-E6, there's already a DIY for this httpss://cheesycam.com/jag35-lp-e6-battery-solutions/

  3. Julien

    i mad some googling with the name of the product and found some online shop where i can buy one, the shops are all in Europe, but i'm planning to buy the 352 led light and add the new adaptator from ikan, i don't know if it's possible?

  4. Emm

    Post author

    @Julien - Looks good, don't see where to buy one. I wouldn't send my Credit information directly to them..

  5. Emm

    Post author

    @andrew00 - Depends on the lens. If you're using a longer lens you can shoot through the ring without seeing it. If you're on a wide lens, then you'd have to be closer to the ring. The stage for the camera is adjustable back and forth as well as up and down.

  6. andrew00

    Can you focus w/the ring light? As it looks to be covering up the focus ring which would inhibit manual control for video work.

  7. Emm

    Post author

    @Jeremy Peters - This 352 LED ring light is brighter and has a further throw. The fluorescent ones spread out with a softer light. I would also be very careful trying to travel with the Fluorescent lights.

  8. Emm

    Post author

    @Rick - The Z96 was used as a baseline to show how much more brighter the Ring Light is. This quick review is not meant to be compared as equal lights (obviously). 4 Z96's would still not be as bright, but diffusion would be better. (4) Z96 LED's would also be more expensive. Position of lights to subject (placed properly) were to simulate On Camera use directly in front of subject. This ring light is traditionally mounted to a camera with the lens through the middle.

    If the question is 'Would 4 Z96's be better?', then my answer would be no. It still would not be as bright, but you would probably have less shadows with a larger light source.

  9. Rick

    Excellent apples to oranges comparison. (Please try this again with 4 properly placed Z96 lights and give us some real information.)

  10. Emm

    Post author

    @Olphus - The ring light traditionally is used for putting your lens through the center. This means your subject would be looking directly into it. The Z96 on a hotshoe is a smaller light and is at least offset from the lens. It might be better to use this ring light off camera for a person, but if you're filming an area, or some type of decor, it would provide even lighting.

    Adding more Z96's together doesn't make the lights brighter, it just makes the area of coverage more diffused. The larger your light source, the softer the light. Using 4 Z96's would cover more area than a single ring light. The Ring Light would still be brighter.

  11. Jermey Peters

    So do you think that the Fluorescent Ring Light will be more comfortable for a subject to stare at directly rather the 352 LED Ring Light for video.

  12. Olphus

    You say "Even though this ring light is dimmable, it’s a very bright source of light that might be uncomfortable for your subject to stare at directly." So, is it too bright even when dimmed down to the lower settings?

    How would the 352 LED Ring light compare to 4 x Z96 lights - which one gives out more light?

Comments are closed.